Saw is my favorite horror movie franchise of all time, and I'm not ashamed to admit it. It's true that the franchise is not the scariest and maybe focuses too much on the blood and gore. It's true that the acting is not always the best and some parts of the movies are absolutely ridiculous. With all of these things in mind, I still love the franchise. I may do a retrospective on the entire franchise in the future, but for now I want to focus on the film that started it all.
I was too young to see Saw in theaters, and unfortunately I saw Saw II before seeing the first movie. My brother had seen it and had raved about how good it was, saying it was one of the most clever and well made horror movies in a long time. Being the horror fanatic that I am, I knew that I had to see this movie, and when my brother received Saw on DVD one Christmas, I finally got my chance to see it.
The thing that I love the most about the movie, and what keeps drawing me back to it, is the overall tone. This is not the "torture porn" movies that the sequels have unfortunately granted the franchise. It plays out more as a suspenseful mystery thriller, with only one scene of actual torture in the entire movie. Every scene in the movie, whether it be a flashback or another cut to the two main characters, plays a crucial role in building up the tension leading up to the climax. Not one scene in the movie is filler, and watching a second time makes the double meanings clearer. It was clear that the story was planned carefully to the final detail.
Looking into some of the behind-the-scenes work on the movie, I can't help but give the producers immense props. Saw only had a budget of around $1 million, but it grossed more than $103 million worldwide. That's an incredible feet for a movie, let alone an R-rated horror movie, as R-rated movies have much smaller audiences and therefore have more difficulty making money. On top of that, this wasn't a remake, reboot or sequel/prequel. This was an original, fresh story, and I believe the low budget helped it in the long run, especially after seeing how the quality of the franchise changed due to the increase in budget with each film.
To go along with the low budget, there are only two or three scenes of real gore in Saw. The rest of the film relies on the strength of the characters and plot to deliver the thrills and tension. It's a shame that the sequels veered away from this and placed more emphasis on the traps, because the film's best moments are when the characters are simply talking to each other. With a story like this, you need strong actors to play the roles, and Cary Elwes and Leigh Whannell carry their scenes incredibly. I was always so invested in their dialogue between each other and legitimately wondered whether they were going to survive Jigsaw's game.
On the subject of the characters, every character in Saw was well written. I was easily invested in their stories and whether or not they would live to the end. Also, the characters are intelligent and rarely, if not at all, make any of the typical horror movie victim mistakes tat plagues most horror movies today. Some horror films try to take itself seriously but fail, partially because of the incompetence of the characters, but Saw avoids this problem.
The iconic scene that everybody remembers from Saw is the reverse bear trap, and it remains to this day as one of my favorite scenes in the franchise. The interesting thing is the event was told in a flashback, so you would think the scene would lack tension and suspense. Even with this in mind, when I first saw this scene, I almost forgot that it was a flashback and was instantly terrified for Amanda, whom Shawnee Smith delivered an amazing performance of. There wasn't a lot of gore involved, but the trap still had immense tension, something that future Saw traps would unfortunately lack in favor of extreme gore.
Finally, the twist ending. I won't spoil it, and I've probably already said too much by saying there is a twist ending in the first place, but it is absolutely one of if not the best ending to a film to date. I cannot begin to describe how shocked I was at the ending. Not only did it surprise me, but it tied together everything that had happened in the film. This would become a tradition to have a twist ending in all of the sequels, all with various degrees of shock value, but the ending to Saw will always remain the strongest.
With the recent release of Evil Dead, I started to think back on the quality of horror films in this generation. It's not hard to acknowledge that the Saw franchise has inspired the high amounts of gore in horror films today. Still, I find myself returning back to the first film because of how carefully crafted it was, despite the limited shooting time frame. There are few standouts this generation that do favor the story and atmosphere over the blood and gore, but Saw will always remain my favorite.